An appeal for independent technical due diligence before committing public money to large-scale coal gasification.
Abstract
India’s indigenous coal gasification initiative offers significant opportunities for import substitution and domestic value addition. However, the proposed Lakhanpur coal-to-ammonium nitrate project raises important questions about the commercial readiness of BHEL’s Pressurised Fluidised Bed Gasification technology. The article examines technology maturity, scale-up challenges, coal suitability and the need for independent technical validation before large-scale public investment.
Introduction
India’s ambition to develop indigenous coal gasification technology is both desirable and strategically important. With substantial domestic coal reserves and dependence on imported chemical feedstocks, coal gasification offers opportunities for import substitution and value addition. However, an important question arises in connection with the proposed ₹25,016 crore
Coal-to-Ammonium Nitrate project at Lakhanpur, Odisha.
The project, being implemented by Bharat Coal Gasification and Chemicals Limited (BCGCL), a joint venture of Coal India Limited (51%) and Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited (49%), is designed to produce 2,000 tonnes per day of ammonium nitrate using BHEL’s indigenous Pressurised Fluidised Bed Gasification (PFBG) technology.
The question is not whether India should develop indigenous technology. It certainly should. The question is whether the technology has undergone adequate demonstration and independent validation before being deployed at this commercial scale.
The Question of Technology Maturity
BHEL has a history of coal gasification development at its Trichy Combined Cycle Demonstration Plant (CCDP). The historical 168 TPD gasifier was developed for an Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) power-generation application. It was an air-blown gasifier producing low-calorific-value producer gas. BHEL has reported substantial cumulative operating experience at Trichy. However, the published historical operating figures need to be examined carefully, particularly to distinguish the operating experience of the original moving-bed gasifier from that of the subsequent fluidised-bed installation. More importantly, the original air-blown demonstration is not equivalent to the present oxygen-blown gasification process intended to produce synthesis gas for chemical manufacture. BHEL has also undertaken smaller-scale pilot development for coal-to-chemicals applications. The critical question is whether the present commercial design has been adequately validated under sustained operating conditions, using coal representative of the proposed Lakhanpur feedstock.
The Scale-up Question
The proposed commercial gasification island is of an entirely different order of magnitude from the earlier demonstration facilities. Scale-up of a fluidised-bed gasifier is not simply a matter of increasing reactor dimensions and coal throughput.
It involves complex interactions between:
– Coal reactivity and particle-size distribution.
– Ash composition and fusion characteristics.
– Bed hydrodynamics and temperature control.
– Carbon conversion and unconverted carbon in ash.
– Coal feeding and continuous ash discharge.
– Oxygen consumption and cold-gas efficiency.
– Long-term availability and operating reliability.
Indian coal presents additional challenges because of its generally high ash content and variable ash chemistry. Consequently, successful operation on one coal cannot automatically establish suitability for another. Has representative Lakhanpur washed coal and washery rejects been subjected to extended gasification trials? Have these trials demonstrated stable bed operation, acceptable carbon conversion and consistent synthesis-gas quality?
Conclusion
These are questions that deserve public answers. Is a contractual guarantee sufficient? BHEL has received the gasification and raw syngas-cleaning package from BCGCL. However, BHEL is itself a 49% promoter of BCGCL. Coal India holds the remaining 51%. A performance guarantee between two government-controlled entities is not necessarily equivalent to transferring the underlying technology risk to an independent technology provider. If the process fails to achieve sustained commercial operation, the consequences could include delayed commissioning, cost escalation, modifications to the gasification island and underutilisation of the downstream ammonia.
Editor’s Note: Experts from the industry are welcome to send their views/comments to the above.




